Lao Tzu and the Variable Behind the Yielding
Lao Tzu said water wins by yielding, never by force. So why do the rest of us grip and push when giving way would carry the day?
There is a line in the Tao Te Ching I have come back to for most of my adult life. Lao Tzu wrote that nothing in the world is softer or more yielding than water, and yet nothing is better at wearing down what is hard and strong. Sit with that for a moment. Water doesn't argue with the rock. It doesn't brace itself, it doesn't swing, it doesn't try to win. It keeps moving, takes the shape of whatever it meets, goes low where everything else is fighting to go high, and given enough time the rock is the thing that gives way. The soft outlasts the hard. The yielding outlasts the rigid. He wasn't writing a nature poem. He was telling us how to live, and I don't think most of us know how to hear it.
Lao Tzu had a name for the way water moves. He called it wu wei. People translate it as non-action, and that has fooled a lot of readers into thinking he wanted us to go limp and do nothing. That isn't it at all. Wu wei is action without forcing. It's doing the thing the moment actually calls for without throwing your whole stiffened will against it, without fighting a current you are already standing in. The farmer doesn't yank the crops upward to make them grow. The good carpenter follows the grain instead of hacking across it. There is real work in wu wei, sometimes a great deal of it. What's missing is the strain, the shoving, the need to contend.
Here's where I've always gotten caught, because I know the teaching is right and I still catch myself doing the opposite of it. I grip. I push. I meet a hard thing by getting harder. When someone comes at me with a strong position, everything in me wants to plant my feet and shove back, which is exactly what water never does and exactly why so many arguments end with both people more locked in than they were at the start. I have walked out of conversations that I technically won and felt no better for it, because winning that way just hands the other person a reason to come back harder. Lao Tzu could see all of this plainly twenty-five centuries ago. What he didn't do, at least not in words I could reach for in the middle of a tense conversation, was name the thing that makes us grip in the first place.
That's the piece I think the Tao Te Ching leaves open. Why can't we move like water? It isn't that we never learned how. We grip because we're afraid. We're afraid of losing, afraid of looking weak, afraid the other person will take everything if we give an inch. Fear is what turns a person rigid, and a rigid person cannot yield, cannot adapt, cannot find the low path around the rock. Fear is the hardness. It is the one thing water never carries, and it is the reason the rest of us can't do what water does without thinking about it.
I started writing conflict down as a kind of formula back in 2009, early on an April morning, and it has held up for me every year since. It goes like this. Start with what you actually Know about the situation in front of you. Add Understanding, the ability to stand where the other person is standing and see what they see. Then take the Fear out. K + (U - F) = S. Understanding can't come up to full strength while Fear is still in the room, and the Fear is really a signal that I am missing Knowledge. So I go and get the Knowledge. The Fear settles, true Understanding arrives, and a Solution that was invisible a moment earlier becomes possible.
A Solution by itself isn't the end of it, though. A Solution reached without Wisdom is just another way to win, another rock thrown at somebody's head. So there is a second stage. S + W = P. The Solution, carried with the Wisdom to know when to hold firm and when to let the water go around, leads to Peace. Not a truce. Not one side flattening the other and calling the silence that follows a victory. Peace, which is the only outcome that doesn't quietly plant the seed of the next fight.
This is what finally let me feel like I understood Lao Tzu instead of just admiring him. Water's secret is that it has nothing to defend. It carries no Fear, so it never needs to contend. It can afford to go low, to yield, to take any shape it is handed, because it isn't afraid of losing itself in the process. That is wu wei. Not the absence of effort, the absence of Fear. I wrote once about Sun Tzu, who said the best general wins without fighting, and about Thich Nhat Hanh, who told us to come back to the breath before we act. They are pointing at the same move from different directions. When I stop defending and actually go find out what the person across from me is afraid of, my own Fear settles, and then I can give way on the thing that never mattered to me and stand quietly firm on the thing that does. From the outside it looks soft. It wins anyway, and nobody leaves bleeding.
Lao Tzu said a journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step. I would only add that the first step isn't out there somewhere, in the other person or the circumstance or the argument you are rehearsing in the car. It is closer than that. It is taking the Fear out of your own two hands so they can finally open. The water was never trying. It simply was not afraid.
If this is the way you want to meet the hard things in your own life, the book lays the whole formula out from the beginning.
P.N. Yaya