Gandhi, King, and the Variable Behind Nonviolence

Gandhi called a coward incapable of real nonviolence. The discipline starts by putting down your own Fear, before you face anyone else's.

Everyone thinks they know what nonviolence looks like. A man sits down at a counter where he is not wanted, and when the blows come, he does not raise his hands. A line of marchers walks toward the dogs and the fire hoses and keeps walking. We call it restraint, and somewhere underneath the admiration most of us file it next to weakness, the thing you do when you cannot or will not fight. Both of the men most responsible for that picture spent their lives saying we had it exactly backward.

Gandhi was blunt about it in a way that still surprises people. He said that between a coward and a violent man, he would choose the violent man every time, because at least the violent man has not run from his own Fear. A coward, he said, cannot be nonviolent. The two cannot live in the same person. If the only reason you are keeping your hands down is that you are too frightened to lift them, you are not practicing anything. You are just afraid. And when Gandhi listed the disciplines he asked of the people around him, he did not put nonviolence at the top. He put fearlessness there. Non-harm came after. First you become unafraid. Then, and only then, can you refuse to do harm and have it mean something.

Why would the man most identified with nonviolence rank fearlessness ahead of it? Because he understood where violence actually comes from. The hand that strikes is almost never calm. It is cornered. The person who lashes out is defending something he is scared to lose, his position, his pride, his sense that he controls the room. Whole systems of domination run on the same fuel, the ruler afraid of the ruled and the ruled afraid of the ruler, each one certain the other will destroy him the moment he lowers his guard. So nonviolence was never really the absence of a weapon. It was the removal of the Fear in the person who had decided to set the weapon down, and the strangely disarming effect that calm has on everyone watching.

King said it in his own key. He was careful to tell people that nonviolent resistance is not a method for cowards. It resists. It is active, it confronts, it does not wait politely for justice to arrive. But its aim, he insisted, is not to defeat the opponent or to humiliate him. The aim is to win his Understanding, even his friendship, and to come out the other side with something he called the beloved community. He was not trying to win a fight. He was trying to end the reason for it. "Hate cannot drive out hate," he wrote, "only love can do that." Read that as strategy and not sentiment and it tells you exactly what he was doing. He was refusing to hand the other side the Fear that would justify their next blow.

This is the ground my own work stands on, and it is why, when I wrote the Peace Formula down in 2009, I wrote it in two stages and not one. The first stage is this: Knowledge plus Understanding, with Fear taken out, gives you a Solution. K + (U - F) = S. The Knowledge is of the other person as a human being, the plain facts of who he is and what he is protecting. The Understanding is the harder thing, the willingness to see the situation through his eyes, even when his eyes are the ones that frighten you. And the Fear has to come out, because Understanding cannot come up to full strength while Fear is still in the room. Here is the part people miss. Your Fear is not an enemy to be shamed. It is a signal. It is telling you that you are missing some piece of Knowledge about this person or this moment. Go and get that Knowledge, and the Fear comes down on its own, and Understanding finally has room to stand up.

But notice that the first stage ends at a Solution, and a Solution is not where Gandhi and King were trying to arrive. A desegregated counter is a Solution. A country that governs itself is a Solution. So is a settlement, a verdict, a signed agreement. And every one of them can be won in a way that leaves the other side crushed and waiting, which is to say, in a way that plants the next conflict in the same soil. This is the thing Sun Tzu saw from the other direction when he warned against cornering an enemy, a foe with no way out fights to the death. Gandhi and King knew it too. A win that humiliates is not Peace. It is an intermission. That is what the second stage is for. S + W = P. The Solution, carried with Wisdom, aimed at reconciliation instead of conquest, leads to Peace. Wisdom is what keeps you from using your Solution as a club. It is the difference between beating your opponent and freeing him, and in the end yourself, from the quarrel.

I want to be honest about which part is hard, because it is not the formula. The formula is simple enough to carry in your head. The hard part is the subtraction, and it is hard for the exact reason Gandhi named. You cannot take the Fear out while you are still inside it. Frightened, you reach for the opposite of Knowledge. You assign the worst motive, you brace, you look for the nearest weapon. The whole discipline of nonviolence, all the training and the breathing and the refusal to strike back, is really one long practice of getting the Fear down first so that everything after it can move. Gandhi put fearlessness at the top of the list because nothing below it works until that one is done.

You are probably not standing in front of an empire. You are standing in front of your husband, or a coworker who went around you, or a stranger whose tone put you on guard. The scale is smaller and the move is identical. Before you decide what to do, put down your own Fear. Go find the thing you do not yet know about the person across from you. Then the Solution you reach will be one you can live beside. That is the whole of it, and it is the quietest kind of strength there is.

P.N. Yaya is the author of The Principle of Peace: Transforming Fear into Understanding. Get the book →